| Subject: slat armor for stryker |
 | Steve Joyce blaster76 | Location: Texas, United States Member Since: September 15, 2002
Posts: 8,154 entire network,
2,103 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 03:32 AM UTC |
|
I am building the AFV M1130 Stryker kit. I bought the Eduard brass slat armor, and after a few steps, it is proving itself to be most dificult and time consumng. (2 hours to bend 3 parts and glue 6 together). I was wondering if someone has recently made a plastic alternative. Or at least the brace pieces done that way. |
Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it
VMI "76
Order of the Red Nose Plug
Blue Volute Bumper Spring Award
| |  |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
| Robert Skipper 18Bravo | Location: Colorado, United States Member Since: January 20, 2005
Posts: 2,180 entire network,
374 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 06:12 AM UTC |
|
Check out Pro Art. I don't know if they do a set for that particular Stryker, but my set for the M1126 came with a huge bag of resin - braces, armor, and much more. These sets are well worth investigating. |
A strong man stands up for himself; A stronger man stands up for others.
Admit nothing.
Deny everything.
Make counter-accusations. | | |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | Andy Renshaw skyhawk | Location: Florida, United States Member Since: June 03, 2003
Posts: 486 entire network,
15 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 06:20 AM UTC |
|
im working on the Griffion set right now, and its not bad, though a LOT more parts than eduard because they actully made the etch like the real thing. Eduard took some shortcuts on a few areas. I think the metal is much thicker in the Griffion stuff than Eduard. Somewhere on here was a long thread that some folks had commented on how the eduard stuff was super thin and hard to deal with.
Also if im not mistaken, the Pro Art set is eduard, just with resin tubes replacing the PE ones.
I also recomend a Hold-n-fold type tool. The Bug is probally just the right size to do this. |
| Fideli Certa Merces -- "to the faithful there is certain reward" | |  |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | Arnold Lucero sopmod6 | Location: Missouri, United States Member Since: March 31, 2005
Posts: 554 entire network,
115 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 06:35 AM UTC |
|
My review from long ago on another thread...
Having recently acquired the Griffon Stryker set, I can say it is probably the best of all of them; The set costs significantly more, but the parts breakdown and layout on the sheets makes it easier to find per the instruction sheets. The scale thickness is more manageable than that of the other brands ( I bought multiple sets of each brand), but is on par with the PAM set. The Eduard set is as Mother put it, "bends under your breath. I'm currently working on that set and will have to agree. Soldering the stuff is a meat grinder too. Since Ed decided to release everything in sets to breakdown assembly, I find it harder to keep up with all the multiple etch sheets to find out what goes where. Aaaay!... The Voyager set is THIN. Nice, but too thin for scale thickness. Nuff said. The ProArts set is a head scratcher. Ease of assembly? Yes. Less parts? Yes. Nice CD instructions? Yes. Sacrificial Lamb for easier build. Most Definitely. For those who want as realistic as possible, you're better off with any of the other three sets. PAM decided to cast the space armor and hull plates together, so there is no see- through gap in between. The front part of the space armor is also made in PE, so you have to make sure that when assembling that front half, it lines flush with the rear resin half. I'd preferred if the whole thing was etch. Resin parts are nicely cast, but some are better off in PE due to I SWEAR TO GOD SUPER DUPER FRAGILE PIECES! The square tubing in resin is a very nice touch. I only had 4 broken pieces between my three sets. The etch frets came in on big sheet, folded multiple times(MULTIPLE) with spacer cards in between.
All the sets parts are broken down in pretty similar fashion for assembly. Copies of each other? Maybe to a degree. The size of parts are different though; Griffons exhaust is larger than that of Ed by a bit. The square tubing in all sets range from 1 to 1.75mm in diameter. Once I'm done with this Ed set, it'll be my last. I'll be going with the Griffon brand after that, and just putting the others away for, oh, whenever....
Hope this simple quick review helped some... REPLY REPLY & QUOTE EDIT DELETE
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
| Robert Skipper 18Bravo | Location: Colorado, United States Member Since: January 20, 2005
Posts: 2,180 entire network,
374 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 06:37 AM UTC |
|
Quoted Text
Also if im not mistaken, the Pro Art set is eduard, just with resin tubes replacing the PE ones.
Speaking only for the M1126, the fret has "Pro Art Models" and "Made in Belgium" etched into it. |
A strong man stands up for himself; A stronger man stands up for others.
Admit nothing.
Deny everything.
Make counter-accusations. | | |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | Steve Joyce blaster76 | Location: Texas, United States Member Since: September 15, 2002
Posts: 8,154 entire network,
2,103 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 06:43 AM UTC |
|
I've got a hold and fold, but that bras is just too thin. I figure if the main braces are plastic or resin, it would be easier to slip in the slats rather than fight wth the whole assembly each time you tuch it. I'll have to check out the pro arts, any body know who sells it. |
Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it
VMI "76
Order of the Red Nose Plug
Blue Volute Bumper Spring Award
| |  |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | Steve Joyce blaster76 | Location: Texas, United States Member Since: September 15, 2002
Posts: 8,154 entire network,
2,103 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 06:43 AM UTC |
|
I've got a hold and fold, but that bras is just too thin. I figure if the main braces are plastic or resin, it would be easier to slip in the slats rather than fight wth the whole assembly each time you tuch it. I'll have to check out the pro arts, any body know who sells it. |
Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it
VMI "76
Order of the Red Nose Plug
Blue Volute Bumper Spring Award
| |  |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | Arnold Lucero sopmod6 | Location: Missouri, United States Member Since: March 31, 2005
Posts: 554 entire network,
115 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 06:50 AM UTC |
|
You're better going off and replacing those brace parts with square plastic rod. I did that on Advice from Mother and it is a better all-around solution. |
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
| Miloslav Hraban bulivyf | Location: Praha, Czech Republic Member Since: April 03, 2006
Posts: 1,406 entire network,
0 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 08:32 AM UTC |
|
Hi Steve Joyce, I Have three Eduard Slat ready and Two Eduard in progress. Also Griffon and Voyager in progress. If you have problem with Eduard no try next because Eduadr is easy for build. Griffon and Voyager have very problematic instruction. Pro Art I no build but here is very unrealistic Add-on Armor from resin. I can advise you if you need with some Eduard slat problem but please you must have many patience because Slat you don't build on two or three day. I build this seven day 10 hour daily. Miloslav |
| Hope you like it and "watch those negative waves" | |  |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | John Linford johnlinford | Location: England - South West, United Kingdom Member Since: October 28, 2006
Posts: 133 entire network,
3 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 09:02 AM UTC |
|
HI Steve , I also am building the Eduard slat ( look at long time sat down thread on modern US ) and it is most time consuming thing to do. I have done a bit in between other projects , just wish I could dedicate the time that Miloslav does , cannot wait to see his finished models. Just keep at it , think of the finished product , they look amazing. All the best, John. |
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
|
|
 | Jason Mansfield abramstnkr | Location: California, United States Member Since: July 15, 2007
Posts: 15 entire network,
0 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 09:37 AM UTC |
|
Quoted Text
HI Steve , I also am building the Eduard slat ( look at long time sat down thread on modern US ) and it is most time consuming thing to do. I have done a bit in between other projects , just wish I could dedicate the time that Miloslav does , cannot wait to see his finished models. Just keep at it , think of the finished product , they look amazing. All the best, John.
He is right. Here's 2 I've done. Not sure who said it but going with the square plastic strip for the top and bottom parts of the frame and then the photo etch sides is the best way to go. Basically, cut the plastic strips to size, cut the photo etch side frames of that section off, glue all 4 pieces together, start gluing the slats in place and then add the middle photo etch support strip. It takes some time but you eventually get the hang of it.   |
Tattoo on the lower back? Might as well be a bullseye.
Do you know how I know you're gay? Because you are holding each other ever so gently
Better Lucky than Good! | | |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
| Miloslav Hraban bulivyf | Location: Praha, Czech Republic Member Since: April 03, 2006
Posts: 1,406 entire network,
0 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 09:57 AM UTC |
|
Quoted Text
Quoted Text
HI Steve , I also am building the Eduard slat ( look at long time sat down thread on modern US ) and it is most time consuming thing to do. I have done a bit in between other projects , just wish I could dedicate the time that Miloslav does , cannot wait to see his finished models. Just keep at it , think of the finished product , they look amazing. All the best, John.
He is right. Here's 2 I've done. Not sure who said it but going with the square plastic strip for the top and bottom parts of the frame and then the photo etch sides is the best way to go. Basically, cut the plastic strips to size, cut the photo etch side frames of that section off, glue all 4 pieces together, start gluing the slats in place and then add the middle photo etch support strip. It takes some time but you eventually get the hang of it.


Wow! I don't know that many modelers build Slat. Maybe you can place here some photos as Jason. Jason, Excellent and very clear Slat build. Miloslav |
| Hope you like it and "watch those negative waves" | |  |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | Jason Mansfield abramstnkr | Location: California, United States Member Since: July 15, 2007
Posts: 15 entire network,
0 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 10:23 AM UTC |
|
By the way, I did use the Eduard sets, along with 2 brand new "Tweezerman" tweezers. Those tweezers are expensive but well worth it. As for the glue I used regular cyanoacrylate, CA Thin glue. After the model was built, I gave it a base coat of the primary color, let that dry and then added a coulpe coats of "Future" to make the slat armor joints a bit stronger. I let that dry and then added another coat of the base color, let that dry and then went on to decaling and then weathering. I just did a Canadian 2A6M with slat as well. I'll post pics of it soon.
Thanks Miloslav! |
Tattoo on the lower back? Might as well be a bullseye.
Do you know how I know you're gay? Because you are holding each other ever so gently
Better Lucky than Good! | | |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | Joe Szczygielski mother
Associate Editor
| Location: New York, United States Member Since: January 29, 2004
Posts: 3,048 entire network,
1,024 this site
|  | |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 04:01 PM UTC |
|
I’ve built several Stryker’s in the past including 7 with slat armor. I admit I to was pulling out my hair during my first time at it. My second and third time around I learned a few tricks and the rest were a piece of cake. I replaced the upper, lower and main supports using Evergreen Plastic rod, 1.5mm square rod. Here is how I go about it which work well for me. Everything is glued using super glue, the blue bottle “super thin” type. I’ll pour some out on the frosted side of the CD. This side keeps the glue longer while the writing side cures faster, not sure why. Anyhow I’ll pick the glue up with a tooth pic and touch the connection. There are times I’ll also use an accelerator to speed drying time. Yes you’ll find yourself wondering why you started such a project, but keep at it, take breaks at times but keep chugging away at it. In the end you’ll see the light at the end of the tunnel and you’ll be glad and excited once it’s finished and painted. Good Luck and Happy Modeling, Joe |
| It feels like bible camp…Only I’m not crying pretending I’m somewhere else. | |  |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |
 | Steve Joyce blaster76 | Location: Texas, United States Member Since: September 15, 2002
Posts: 8,154 entire network,
2,103 this site
|  |  |
|
|
| Posted: Monday, October 05, 2009 - 06:15 PM UTC |
|
Thanks Joe
I'm copying your instructions. I've done some tough kits some of those new 350 scale Japanese battleships are a bugger at times, but there I always was gluing onto a plastic structure. I'll be getting some of that super glue and work with it, maybe that will at least speed things up as I won't be having the work I've done fall apart and have to restart If you ant to see another toughie, take a look at the underdeck stuff on the 350 scale Akagi. Same sort of deal but once again I'll be gluing to a hard piece of plastic. |
Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it
VMI "76
Order of the Red Nose Plug
Blue Volute Bumper Spring Award
| |  |
|
| HIDE SIGNATURE AREAS |
 |